|
Post by rayc5678 on Nov 5, 2017 11:43:28 GMT -6
For those of you curious, yes, I did change the title of the thread (due to me editing my first post). I'm also thinking about dropping Wonder Woman, Harley Quinn, Jean Grey, Olivia Pope, The Doctor (Female Incarnation), and Kate O'Brian from the list and replacing them with some different names, to hopefully get some votes for them. What do you guys think?
Claire Bennet (Heroes) (12)
Penny Hofstadter (The Big Bang Theory) (8)
Kitty Pryde/Shadowcat (5)
Mia/Anita Hawkins (Humans) (3)
Daisy Johnson (Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.) (1)
Dr. Elliot Reid (Scrubs) (1)
Valkyrie (Thor: Ragnarok) (1)
Diana Prince/Wonder Woman (0)
Harleen Quinnzel/Harley Quinn (0)
Jean Grey (0)
Olivia Pope (Scandal) (0)
The Doctor (Female Incarnation) (0)
Kate O'Brian (The Drew Carey Show) (0)
|
|
|
Post by chronoeclipse on Nov 5, 2017 13:26:04 GMT -6
I'd say wait until someone reaches 20 before removing anyone from the list. Then maybe once the first 20 is posted removing anyone who had received 0 votes. We could also at that point start a rule where you can vote for a person AND nominate a new person to the list every day but anyone with 0 points once a new character reaches 20 is removed. I think the new characters added to the list should happen organically from what everyone is inspired to include in the moment.
Claire Bennet (Heroes) (12)
Penny Hofstadter (The Big Bang Theory) (8)
Kitty Pryde/Shadowcat (6)
Mia/Anita Hawkins (Humans) (3)
Daisy Johnson (Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.) (1)
Dr. Elliot Reid (Scrubs) (1)
Valkyrie (Thor: Ragnarok) (1)
Diana Prince/Wonder Woman (0)
Harleen Quinnzel/Harley Quinn (0)
Jean Grey (0)
Olivia Pope (Scandal) (0)
The Doctor (Female Incarnation) (0)
Kate O'Brian (The Drew Carey Show) (0)
|
|
|
Post by fan2000 on Nov 5, 2017 16:18:08 GMT -6
Claire Bennet (Heroes) (13) Penny Hofstadter (The Big Bang Theory) (8) Kitty Pryde/Shadowcat (6) Mia/Anita Hawkins (Humans) (3) Daisy Johnson (Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.) (1) Dr. Elliot Reid (Scrubs) (1) Valkyrie (Thor: Ragnarok) (1) Diana Prince/Wonder Woman (0) Harleen Quinnzel/Harley Quinn (0) Jean Grey (0) Olivia Pope (Scandal) (0) The Doctor (Female Incarnation) (0) Kate O'Brian (The Drew Carey Show) (0)
|
|
|
Post by rayc5678 on Nov 5, 2017 17:12:09 GMT -6
Okay, I've decided. No other name's will be added to the list until the the first three names get 20 votes each. After that, 3 new names can be put onto the list to make up for the first 3. Once the 3 new names are on, only one other name will be added once a name gets 20 votes. For example, Elliot Reid is the fourth name to get 20 votes, then someone can add a name to the list. Then once Kitty Pryde (for example) becomes the fifth name to get 20 votes, another name can be added, and so forth. That work for everyone?
Claire Bennet (Heroes) (14)
Penny Hofstadter (The Big Bang Theory) (8)
Kitty Pryde/Shadowcat (6)
Mia/Anita Hawkins (Humans) (3)
Daisy Johnson (Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.) (1)
Dr. Elliot Reid (Scrubs) (1)
Valkyrie (Thor: Ragnarok) (1)
Diana Prince/Wonder Woman (0)
Harleen Quinnzel/Harley Quinn (0)
Jean Grey (0)
Olivia Pope (Scandal) (0)
The Doctor (Female Incarnation) (0)
Kate O'Brian (The Drew Carey Show) (0)
|
|
|
Post by chronoeclipse on Nov 5, 2017 17:32:44 GMT -6
My question with this new rule for adding names would be - who then gets to add people to the list? Will you be the only one allowed to add new characters to the list? If it's open to everyone to do so but only restricted to 1 new name any time someone reaches 20 votes then it's likely that multiple folks will be clamoring to add a new character. Currently we have a list of 13 women. That feels like an odd number of 'contestants'. As I mentioned previously - I really like the idea that one can add a person to the list when they feel inspired to nominate them. Maybe others disagree. It'll also make for a boring game if we only care about 1 or 2 characters on the list. I've never watched Scandal and no one has seen the female Doctor yet because she doesn't debut until next year. If we are all voting for the same handful of people while the majority of characters are sitting at 0 or 1 vote each that makes it less interesting in my opinion.
Claire Bennet (Heroes) (14)
Penny Hofstadter (The Big Bang Theory) (8)
Kitty Pryde/Shadowcat (6)
Mia/Anita Hawkins (Humans) (3)
Daisy Johnson (Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.) (1)
Dr. Elliot Reid (Scrubs) (2)
Valkyrie (Thor: Ragnarok) (1)
Diana Prince/Wonder Woman (0)
Harleen Quinnzel/Harley Quinn (0)
Jean Grey (0)
Olivia Pope (Scandal) (0)
The Doctor (Female Incarnation) (0)
Kate O'Brian (The Drew Carey Show) (0)
|
|
|
Post by rayc5678 on Nov 5, 2017 17:50:46 GMT -6
I'm not voting in this post, as I posted less than an hour ago.
I was thinking that the person who makes the 20th vote for a character, will get to add on another character to the list (they essentially get 2 votes). How does that sound. As for the current list, I was asking about eliminating the women with zero votes, so the current ones can get more votes. However, I was thinking that we currently replace Olivia Pope, the Female Doctor, and Kate O'Brian, along with adding one more to make the total 14. As for the new names, I was thinking about these.
Melinda Gordon (Ghost Whisperer) Prue Halliwell (Charmed) (Prue has never been aged (as far as I know) on the show) Regina Mills (Once Upon A Time) Pamela Isley/Poison Ivy
Of course, any other names would work. Those are just some names I thought everyone might like.
|
|
|
Post by JackpotMans on Nov 5, 2017 20:02:17 GMT -6
I would do it like this: - Winner gets a write up
- Top 4 voted get to stay
- Rest get replaced
- Keep the list down to 10-15 to keep things fresh
We can redo people that have not been written, but they can't go consecutive rounds (unless they make the top) E.X. no one can add Jean Grey until 2 rounds after this one Claire Bennet (Heroes) (15)Penny Hofstadter (The Big Bang Theory) (8) Kitty Pryde/Shadowcat (6) Mia/Anita Hawkins (Humans) (3) Daisy Johnson (Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.) (1) Dr. Elliot Reid (Scrubs) (2) Valkyrie (Thor: Ragnarok) (1) Diana Prince/Wonder Woman (0) Harleen Quinnzel/Harley Quinn (0) Jean Grey (0) Olivia Pope (Scandal) (0) The Doctor (Female Incarnation) (0) Kate O'Brian (The Drew Carey Show) (0)
|
|
|
Post by youthdrain on Nov 5, 2017 20:16:25 GMT -6
Claire Bennet (Heroes) (15)
Penny Hofstadter (The Big Bang Theory) (9)
Kitty Pryde/Shadowcat (6)
Mia/Anita Hawkins (Humans) (3)
Daisy Johnson (Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.) (1)
Dr. Elliot Reid (Scrubs) (2)
Valkyrie (Thor: Ragnarok) (1)
Diana Prince/Wonder Woman (0)
Harleen Quinnzel/Harley Quinn (0)
Jean Grey (0)
Olivia Pope (Scandal) (0)
The Doctor (Female Incarnation) (0)
Kate O'Brian (The Drew Carey Show) (0)
|
|
|
Post by chronoeclipse on Nov 5, 2017 20:29:10 GMT -6
I would do it like this: - Winner gets a write up
- Top 4 voted get to stay
- Rest get replaced
- Keep the list down to 10-15 to keep things fresh
We can redo people that have not been written, but they can't go consecutive rounds (unless they make the top) E.X. no one can add Jean Grey until 2 rounds after this one I like this suggestion - as it motivates people to vote for their favorites to keep them in the contest. I'd make the cutoff top 5 after the winner though. I'd say if we do it like this - and cut down to 5 each time everyone can nominate one new person a round (By 'round' I mean - each new time we cull down to 5) until we are back up to 10. You snooze, you lose if you aren't one of the first 5 people to nominate a new person that round. As far as taking people off right now and replacing them - i'd say leave them on until we get to 20 with someone if we decide to do it this way.
|
|
|
Post by rayc5678 on Nov 5, 2017 20:53:23 GMT -6
How about this?
Each character gets a write up (their AP description) once they reach 20 votes.
Once the character gets ranked, they can't be be voted for 2-5 rounds (a round equally 2+ characters getting to 20 votes).
Current list will be kept and new characters can be added until we have 20 characters on the list, then it'll be capped then.
|
|
|
Post by fan2000 on Nov 6, 2017 14:26:03 GMT -6
Claire Bennet (Heroes) (16) Penny Hofstadter (The Big Bang Theory) (9) Kitty Pryde/Shadowcat (6) Mia/Anita Hawkins (Humans) (3) Daisy Johnson (Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.) (1) Dr. Elliot Reid (Scrubs) (2) Valkyrie (Thor: Ragnarok) (1) Diana Prince/Wonder Woman (0) Harleen Quinnzel/Harley Quinn (0) Jean Grey (0) Olivia Pope (Scandal) (0) The Doctor (Female Incarnation) (0) Kate O'Brian (The Drew Carey Show) (0)
|
|
|
Post by chronoeclipse on Nov 6, 2017 19:12:24 GMT -6
Once the character gets ranked, they can't be be voted for 2-5 rounds (a round equally 2+ characters getting to 20 votes). I don't understand this part. Are you removing characters from the list or are they remaining on the list but are then people just aren't able to vote for them? Why is a 'round' every time 2 or more people make it to 20 votes? Why wouldn't a new round be every time a new person reaches 20 votes? What didn't you like about what Jackpotman suggested? Claire Bennet (Heroes) (16) Penny Hofstadter (The Big Bang Theory) (9) Kitty Pryde/Shadowcat (6) Mia/Anita Hawkins (Humans) (3) Daisy Johnson (Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.) (1) Dr. Elliot Reid (Scrubs) (3)
Valkyrie (Thor: Ragnarok) (1) Diana Prince/Wonder Woman (0) Harleen Quinnzel/Harley Quinn (0) Jean Grey (0) Olivia Pope (Scandal) (0) The Doctor (Female Incarnation) (0) Kate O'Brian (The Drew Carey Show) (0)
|
|
|
Post by rayc5678 on Nov 6, 2017 19:53:22 GMT -6
Once the character gets ranked, they can't be be voted for 2-5 rounds (a round equally 2+ characters getting to 20 votes). I don't understand this part. Are you removing characters from the list or are they remaining on the list but are then people just aren't able to vote for them? Why is a 'round' every time 2 or more people make it to 20 votes? Why wouldn't a new round be every time a new person reaches 20 votes? What didn't you like about what Jackpotman suggested? Okay, I think I made things more complicated than it was supposed to be. JackpotMans idea is easier, though the last person who votes for a character once they reach 20 votes, can write up the AP description of the character (ex. youthdrain gets the last vote for Kitty Pryde, and gets to write up her AP description, I get the last vote for Penny Hofstadter and get to write up her AP description, JackpotMans gets the last vote for Claire Bennet, and gets to write up her AP description, and so forth). Also, I think characters in the list that don't get the 20 votes, can come back in later rounds, though not consecutively (after 2+ rounds), like JackpotMans said. I was also thinking that after like 8-10 rounds, characters that made the top list for their rounds, can come back to be voted again (ex. Claire Bennet, Penny Hofstadter, Kitty Pryde, Elliot Reid of this list, can come back 8 to 10 rounds later, but not beforehand. As for new lists, I was thinking that each of you could message me with your lists for the next round, and I can post a list the most popular names from everyone's lists and make that list in the new round. Either that or the person who gets the last vote for the character in 4th place (ex. chronoeclipse gets the 20th vote for the character in 4th place) in the round gets to create a new list. What does everyone think? Claire Bennet (Heroes) (16) Penny Hofstadter (The Big Bang Theory) (9) Kitty Pryde/Shadowcat (6) Mia/Anita Hawkins (Humans) (3) Daisy Johnson (Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.) (2) Dr. Elliot Reid (Scrubs) (3) Valkyrie (Thor: Ragnarok) (1) Diana Prince/Wonder Woman (0) Harleen Quinnzel/Harley Quinn (0) Jean Grey (0) Olivia Pope (Scandal) (0) The Doctor (Female Incarnation) (0) Kate O'Brian (The Drew Carey Show) (0)
|
|
|
Post by fan2000 on Nov 7, 2017 13:27:36 GMT -6
Claire Bennet (Heroes) (17)
Penny Hofstadter (The Big Bang Theory) (9)
Kitty Pryde/Shadowcat (6)
Mia/Anita Hawkins (Humans) (3)
Daisy Johnson (Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.) (2)
Dr. Elliot Reid (Scrubs) (3)
Valkyrie (Thor: Ragnarok) (1)
Diana Prince/Wonder Woman (0)
Harleen Quinnzel/Harley Quinn (0)
Jean Grey (0)
Olivia Pope (Scandal) (0)
The Doctor (Female Incarnation) (0)
Kate O'Brian (The Drew Carey Show) (0)
|
|
|
Post by chronoeclipse on Nov 7, 2017 14:28:24 GMT -6
Okay, I think I made things more complicated than it was supposed to be. JackpotMans idea is easier, though the last person who votes for a character once they reach 20 votes, can write up the AP description of the character (ex. youthdrain gets the last vote for Kitty Pryde, and gets to write up her AP description, I get the last vote for Penny Hofstadter and get to write up her AP description, JackpotMans gets the last vote for Claire Bennet, and gets to write up her AP description, and so forth). Also, I think characters in the list that don't get the 20 votes, can come back in later rounds, though not consecutively (after 2+ rounds), like JackpotMans said. I was also thinking that after like 8-10 rounds, characters that made the top list for their rounds, can come back to be voted again (ex. Claire Bennet, Penny Hofstadter, Kitty Pryde, Elliot Reid of this list, can come back 8 to 10 rounds later, but not beforehand. As for new lists, I was thinking that each of you could message me with your lists for the next round, and I can post a list the most popular names from everyone's lists and make that list in the new round. Either that or the person who gets the last vote for the character in 4th place (ex. chronoeclipse gets the 20th vote for the character in 4th place) in the round gets to create a new list. What does everyone think? I think that sounds good to me! - Just to be clear, when one person reaches 20 votes we are wiping the list down to top 5 and building it back up again right? Not just starting over with an entirely new group? As far as adding new people to the list - I think, if we aren't allowing people to add to the list during a regular round, then we should just have whoever voted the most recent person to 20 and does the AP paragraph on them get to fill out the list with 5 or 10 new people in addition to the top 5 that are remaining on the list. If we all send lists to you I think that's too cumbersome and is going to saddle you with tons of 1 vote ties and i'm not sure why we would wait until the 4th round to fill the list back up if we are clearing out a portion of the ballot each time someone reaches 20 votes. Claire Bennet (Heroes) (17) Penny Hofstadter (The Big Bang Theory) (9) Kitty Pryde/Shadowcat (6) Mia/Anita Hawkins (Humans) (3) Daisy Johnson (Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.) (2) Dr. Elliot Reid (Scrubs) (3) Valkyrie (Thor: Ragnarok) (2) Diana Prince/Wonder Woman (0) Harleen Quinnzel/Harley Quinn (0) Jean Grey (0) Olivia Pope (Scandal) (0) The Doctor (Female Incarnation) (0) Kate O'Brian (The Drew Carey Show) (0)
|
|